There’s been a lot of publicity being pumped out by the Government recently about emergency preparedness. The UK Government is telling Britons to have about three days supplies of food, water, medicines etc. They are also recommending that Britons have a wind up or battery VHF FM radio so that the public can hear the BBC’s emergency broadcasts. Good idea but as I said in an other related article, how many people are going to actually trust the BBC to be honest or accurate in their emergency broadcasts? Probably a lot less than some might like to think.
The government’s ‘line’ about why this emergency preparation is needed seems to be centred on the result of cyberattacks on Britain’s infrastructure with hints of today’s bogeyman the Russians being the possible culprit along with Iran. However whilst I recognise that Britain does face threats from foreign nations wanting to disturb Britain’s infrastructure, it’s quite possible that this advice is being given by the Government because they know just how terribly shaky the British national electricity grid has become. The Government are not going to admit that this might be a possibility as some of the potential chaos in the UK electricity and energy grids are down to an over reliance on the much loved, by Government Ministers at least, renewable energy sector.
The list of stuff that the Government have said we should stockpile is reasonable. You need to keep enough food, water, medicines or washing or temporary cooking equipment. That’s sensible advice.
However, as the YouTuber Ringway Manchester, video linked at bottom of page, has said the Government has left one thing out of their published list of essential items and that is emergency two way communications. This puzzled me as the US Government advises its citizens to make use of the different widely available and easily licensable two way radio systems that are available to Americans. These systems are Family Radio Service (FRS), General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS) and Citizens Band Radio (CB) along with the US radio service that is not at first thought of which is the Multiuser Radio Service (MURS).
A search brought up, via AI Assistant, the following advice from the US Government to US citizens.
This reads:
“U.S. Government Recommendations for Emergency Communication
The U.S. government advises using specific radio services as reliable backup communication tools during emergencies when traditional communication methods fail.
Family Radio Service (FRS)
- License Requirement: No license needed.
- Range: Short-range communication, typically effective within a half-mile to two miles depending on conditions.
- Usage: Ideal for family and neighborhood communication.
- Equipment: Operates on 22 channels, commonly found in handheld walkie-talkies.
General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS)
- License Requirement: Requires a $35 FCC license.
- Range: Greater range than FRS, especially when using repeaters, which can extend communication up to 70 miles.
- Usage: Suitable for family and group communications, as well as emergency situations.
- Equipment: Operates on 30 channels, including 22 shared with FRS. GMRS radios can transmit at higher power levels (up to 50 watts).
Citizens Band (CB) Radio
- License Requirement: No license needed.
- Range: Typically 1-5 miles for handheld units; base stations can reach up to 20 miles.
- Usage: Recommended for local emergency communication due to its affordability and ease of use.
- Equipment: Operates on 40 shared channels, primarily in AM mode.”
I’ve done some digging around and the US Federal Communications Commission and the Federal Emergency Management Agency both accept that licence free transceivers and equipment where the licence acquisition is easy for non-technical types, are a valuable adjunct for communications during emergency conditions.
I’m very surprised that the UK Government has not taken a similar approach. I’m not sure I agree with Ringway Manchester’s explanation that the Government hasn’t recommended off network communications to avoid Britons buying the wrong equipment and spattering their communications all over the VHF and UHF spectrum. I disagree with this because the type of equipment that Ringway Manchester is recommending, the licence free 446MHz band is very clearly labelled as such. If it’s got 446 on the box and has the appropriate CE sticker then it’s 446 and you are good to go. You’d have to be a bit more than a doofus in my view to make such a major mistake in transceiver purchases. Ringway Manchester has some good recommendations for value for money 446MHz radios on the video that I’ve linked to below. However if Ringway Manchester’s speculation is correct that this is the reason why off grid comms is not included in emergency advice, then the UK Government has a very dim view of the British public and thinks that we are stupid.
You don’t have to be exceptionally paranoid to wonder whether there was any other more nefarious reason why the UK Government hasn’t pointed the public in the direction of emergency communications equipment in a similar way to how the American government has done. You just need to have experienced a British Government that Dr David Starkey once said has badly governed Britain and which has governed in as bad a manner than we have been since the ‘days of King Stephen’, a period known as ‘The Anarchy’.
Could it be that in the event of a grid failure (something that’s worryingly likely due to the Govt obsession with renewable energy) the Government doesn’t want Britons to talk to others, even with the half mile to a mile that can be achieved with the 16 channels of the 446MHz 0.5Watt radios or even with the 80 channels of CB with more power and more range? With a longer term power outage which might be more than the six days that the national electricity grid is expected to be a worst case scenario, I can see a whole lot of reasons why the Government wouldn’t want Briton talking to Briton. We might find out a whole lot of stuff that might not be being reported on the BBC’s Emergency Broadcasting system? Stuff like where are the criminals taking advantage of no electricity and what they are doing? Is there trouble at this or that location, which supermarket has been the subject of an arson attack or which hospital isn’t looking like a cosplay version of the movie ‘Night of the Living Dead’? There’s a whole lot of stuff that Britons could be talking to each other about during an emergency which the Government might not like them to be talking about.
Putting aside the omission about off grid communications from the Government’s emergency advice, which may just have been an error on the Government’s part, I must admit I agree with Ringway Manchester that 446MHz radios and even CB radios would be a good addition to any Briton’s emergency pack. They are not perfect, they are short range and unencrypted but they might help you keep in touch when the phone system goes down which it may well do if Britain has an extended power outage.
I’m certainly enthused by Ringway Manchester’s video about the potential utility of 446Mhz radios and might try at some point ascending some high hill at night and see of I can reach any members of the various networks that seem to springing up on the 446MHz band at night or see how far I can get. Hobby and general radio chit chat activity on 446 seems to be mostly at night as the band is mostly business use during the day. See Ringway Manchester’s video for more details of these ‘nets’. I might get something interesting or I might get nothing we’ll see. I’ll let you all know what happens.
Links
Ringway Manchester’s video on emergency communications
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ko9_Nkx8Zyg
Dr David Starkey ‘We’ve never been this badly governed’
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yylB-bfY1M




Be the first to comment on "Why would the UK Government not want the public to know about a particular emergency off grid communications technology?"