Video – A nasty ‘guilt by association’ rumour busted.

 

Accusations, allegations, disclosures and rumour are not proof of anything. They are certainly not evidence that a person is guilty of anything criminal or even conduct that could be construed as moral turpitude, they are often statements that are built on nothing. Neither is a person’s association, even if it is an association lasting decades, with a person who is later revealed to be a wrong’un, proof that the person associated with the latterly revealed wrong’un is themselves a wrong’un. It’s possible to know someone really well and still be surprised about some of the things that they might get up to. It doesn’t have to be anything criminal or wrong, it could merely be just that they do something odd or which we might not have expected them to do no matter how long we’ve known them.

The analogy that I like to give about these sorts of situations especially ones where there are guilt by association tales often fed by internet rumours, is one from my own life. Where I grew up and some of the jobs that I did in the media brought me into contact with men and women who were involved, either to a greater or lesser degree, with the notorious mobsters the Kray Twins. However just because my regular cab driver or the guy behind the bar of a pub that I often frequented or those who were the source of media stories, were associated with the Kray’s in one way or another, doesn’t mean that I was an associate of the Kray’s. At one point in East London’s history you could not move for tripping over people who were in some way associated with the Kray’s. These people were either employed by the Kray’s, were friendly with those who were employed by the Kray’s or who were victims of the Kray firm’s criminal activities. There were many of these people such was the extent of the Kray’s activities. Similarly a person whether famous or not who has had dealings with those who turned out to be utter wrong’uns does not mean that the person in question is a wrong’un themselves.

I despise guilt by association accusations because more often than not they are bogus for the reasons I give above. Guilt by association rumours can sometimes make people do stupid and deranged things such the people who have attacked the artwork of Eric Gill the sculptor because it was revealed, many years after the artist’s death, that Gill was an appalling sex offender who abused his children and his dog. The deranged statue wreckers blame the BBC for ‘harbouring’ or ‘approving’ of Gill but the artwork was commissioned by the BBC at a time when none of the proclivities of Gill were known outside of his own family.

From what I know about the Director General of the BBC at that time I certainly do not think that someone like Lord Reith, who led the BBC at the time when Gill was commissioned to produce artworks for BBC Broadcasting House, a man who was a known strict moralist, would have countenanced hiring Gill had he known of Gill’s gross and disgusting activities. Lord Reith after all was the Director General who allegedly sacked staff who got divorced, had affairs or who were gay or whose activities were not aligned with the morality of the 1930’s when the artworks by Gill were commissioned. Gill might have been a wrong’un but that doesn’t mean that Lord Reith was similarly a wrong’un.

The reason for this article is to address the internet rumours about a major UK celebrity who thousands of people believe, without a shred of evidence, is some sort of sex monster. The video below by HG Tudor, a content creator who specialises in analysing narcissism, goes into this case in depth and he has found that the only connection between this celebrity and wrong’uns was that a man who had taught the celebrity to fly later turned out to be a sex offender. The flight instructor was asked by the celebrity to house sit whilst they were away overseas and whilst the celebrity was away the flight instructor and an accomplice brought two teenagers to the house and abused them. The celebrity was not present and was not even in the country when the crimes occurred and it appears that the celebrity disassociated himself from them immediately and assisted the police by telling them what he knew about the pair of abusers, which turned out to be not much at all that was relevant to the case. The flight instructor taught the celebrity to fly, became friends with the celebrity and then used the celebrity’s property for nefarious purposes whilst the celebrity was out of the country. The celebrity himself had no knowledge of or involvement in what his former friends were up to and the revelations about them probably came as much as a shock to him as it did to many others surrounding the flight instructors in question.

The entire reason why this celebrity is being smeared and from what I can gather smeared completely unjustly, is because he by chance ended up in a friendship with someone who later turned out to be a wrong’un. There’s not even enough evidence from what I can see that this particular celebrity is the one who currently has an injunction or a superinjunction banning publication of their alleged proclivities. That’s not enough credible evidence for me to show that this celebrity is himself dodgy and it paints those who have spread this rumour as woefully and stupidly credulous. We are not those who we have met or worked with or even been friends with, we are ourselves and not these other people. We cannot see into other men’s souls or even be aware of all that others might be doing and are therefore not responsible for them nor are we accountable to others.

I’m not sure that I agree with all of HG Tudor’s viewpoints on matters such as the Royal Family or other celebrities but I believe that on the case of the internet rumours about this particular high profile celebrity, HG Tudor is correct. There’s not the evidence to back up these rumours and there’s only a very weak guilt by association story to link him to genuine wrong’uns. Maybe the lesson from this case is that we need to be much more careful about what we believe about people that are presented to us.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17qznXxPDd0

Be the first to comment on "Video – A nasty ‘guilt by association’ rumour busted."

Leave a Reply